Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

[shilton dipper]

Re: Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

i actually quite liked this band
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lcu7OCIqlqE

the cargo album has been played many many times

[sixtyten]

Re: Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

I'm not saying it didn't, it was certainly close enough to hold up in court. I meant it was ridiculous in that it took 20-odd years to become an issue and IMO it reflects on Kookaburra's copyright holder as quite a mean-spirited cash grab. It's not an isolated case either, take the above-mentioned Gotye, for example. He even admits the catchy xylophone (?) riff in Somebody That I Used To Know rips off Baa Baa Black Sheep, yet the song has just hit number one in America and nobody's doubting his songwriting ability. I think there's a thread in the music section of this forum dedicated to songs that sound alike, it happens all the time and I just feel that poor old Greg was made an example of. It's a shame that the news reports of his death are dredging up the Kookaburra story again, proving his fear that that's what he'd be remembered for.

I agree. I only recently found out about the court case, and agree it was mean spirited.
Today I also had a similar experience.. watched the BBC Four Reggae show last night, and dragged out my UB40..
googled the song "Burden Of Shame", only to see a writing credit for Van Morrison!
Yes the sax and vocal tune is the same as "Moondance", but as its Reggae, I'd never really put the two together despite hearing Moondance first.
Can only assume Morrison's lawyers sued as well

As for Goyte, now you mention it, yes I can hear BBBS, but had never noticed before

[Steveland Cleamer]

Re: Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

His flute riff DID plagurise, majorly

I'm not saying it didn't, it was certainly close enough to hold up in court. I meant it was ridiculous in that it took 20-odd years to become an issue and IMO it reflects on Kookaburra's copyright holder as quite a mean-spirited cash grab. It's not an isolated case either, take the above-mentioned Gotye, for example. He even admits the catchy xylophone (?) riff in Somebody That I Used To Know rips off Baa Baa Black Sheep, yet the song has just hit number one in America and nobody's doubting his songwriting ability. I think there's a thread in the music section of this forum dedicated to songs that sound alike, it happens all the time and I just feel that poor old Greg was made an example of. It's a shame that the news reports of his death are dredging up the Kookaburra story again, proving his fear that that's what he'd be remembered for.

[darren]

Re: Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

sorry to hear this.
r i p greg.

[culnara]

Re: Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

RIP Greg

[sixtyten]

Re: Greg Ham R.I.P [1953-2012]

His flute riff DID plagurise, majorly

[Steveland Cleamer]

Greg Ham of 80's Aussie band Men At Work has passed away at age 58.

http://au.news.yahoo.com/entertainme...am-dies-at-58/

Sadly in recent years his musical achievements have been overshadowed by the ridiculous court ruling that his flute riff in the hit "Down Under" plagiarised the old children's song "Kookaburra".

If this is the precedent, why hasn't the copyright owner of "Baa Baa Black Sheep" sued Gotye yet?