Ad_Forums-Top

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

School Punishment

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • scotchmist
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    I went to a cut-throat comprehensive in Glasgow 1978-1984 where the strap was the favoured instrument of correction! If you got on the wrong side of a particularly sadistic male teacher (females could never use the strap correctly....there's a psychological study in the making!) you were in the wet brown mucky stuff! I can remember receiving the strap on a number of occasions for felonies such as running in the corridor and singing in the classroom! Quite tame by today's anarchic standards of deviant teenage behaviour! The pain as this one-inch thick piece of two-pronged leather came down upon your delicate teenage lily-white palm at the speed of light, would practically stop your heart! To be honest I don't think I've felt pain like it since, except that time with my Scout Master...when we shared a sleeping-bag....

    Leave a comment:


  • kazboot
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    My husband was telling me he used to have a board rubber thrown at him on occasion and was once whacked with a blackboard compass! The wingnut gave him a nasty bruise as well. I would consider that excessive punishment myself! He did also say that the boys loved trying to get away with being hurt by the cane by shoving exercise books down the back of their trousers.

    Leave a comment:


  • Marine Boy
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    Originally posted by HappinessDragon View Post
    ...I remember we had a mad woman trying to teach us French in junior school. She'd throw the blackboard rubber and bits of chalk at you if she thought you were misbehaving. It never improved our behaviour or our French, so what was the point?
    You just reminded me of a teacher I once had when I was about 12. He started by throwing bits of chalk at the kids who were not paying attention and then graduated to those heavy wooden board rubbers. Thank goodness his aim was bad - though of course, it is quite likely he was missing on purpose.

    Leave a comment:


  • HappinessDragon
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    Originally posted by Herr Grunwald View Post
    Regular and sustained beatings on the other hand are wrong. If a pupil continued to fail to behave after receiving the cane or other corporal punishment then it's obvious that it's not going to correct their behaviour.
    I agree, mein Herr.
    I'm glad they abolished corporal punishment and don't think it ever worked and should not be brought back.
    I remember we had a mad woman trying to teach us French in junior school. She'd throw the blackboard rubber and bits of chalk at you if she thought you were misbehaving. It never improved our behaviour or our French, so what was the point?

    Leave a comment:


  • kazboot
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    I think I would have to agree with you on all points, Mike. I'm not sure what age it would be acceptable to start it though.

    When you see the lack of discipline and respect in schools at present it does make you wonder what the answer is.

    Leave a comment:


  • HG
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    A good whack never did anyome any harm and if it made people think twice before doing something wrong I don't see the problem with it.

    Regular and sustained beatings on the other hand are wrong. If a pupil continued to fail to behave after receiving the cane or other corporal punishment then it's obvious that it's not going to correct their behaviour.

    Leave a comment:


  • kazboot
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    Originally posted by Herr Grunwald View Post
    There was no cane when I was in junior school between 78 and 82, but the deputy head had a slipper/plimsole called Herbert that was apparently used to deliver a good whack to offending pupils backsides. I never experienced it though being the good boy I am.
    Yeah we believe you, Mike.

    I'm actually surprised it was outlawed as late as 1987.
    Does anyone have an opinion on whether it was a good or bad thing?

    Leave a comment:


  • Paulos
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    A BBC report I've just read states that corporal punishment in state schools in the UK was outlawed in 1986. I left school in 1987 and it was certainly around whilst I was there and although I never got caned friends of mine did.
    I did however at primary school have to stand outside the headmasters room in the corridor facing the wall every break time for a week!!
    Ahhh happy days!

    Leave a comment:


  • HG
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    There was no cane when I was in junior school between 78 and 82, but the deputy head had a slipper/plimsole called Herbert that was apparently used to deliver a good whack to offending pupils backsides. I never experienced it though being the good boy I am.

    Leave a comment:


  • Marine Boy
    replied
    Re: School Punishment

    Hi Kaz

    Well, I was at secondary school between 1974 and 1979. I think the cane was withdrawn during this time. When I started at the school, I remember there was a rumour going round amongst the kids that you could 'refuse' the cane and get suspended for a few days instead, and that many children just agreed to being struck so they could then keep it from their parents. The girls only got the slipper, not the cane.

    At Junior school, we had a very fierce head master, and once again, I believe he kept a cane but rarely used it. The deputy head used to occasionally whack a child's backside though.

    The idea of a teacher using a ruler to strike the palm of an eight year old, seems astonishing now doesn't it?
    Last edited by Marine Boy; 24-03-2010, 18:50.

    Leave a comment:


  • kazboot
    started a topic School Punishment

    School Punishment

    I was wondering when physical punishment was stopped at school.

    My Junior School still used this until I left in 1971.
    Not all teachers did this and the only teacher that did this to me was a male teacher in the second year when I was 8. He used to whack you on the palm of the hand with a ruler.

    When I went to Senior School it was girls only and we never had this, but my husband who went to the adjoining all boys school was still being caned until 1974 when he left.

    Seems incredible now.


Working...
X