Re: Your very petty pet hates
Definitely! Engineers spent a lot of time in the development of television perfecting designs to ensure good picture geometry with perfectly linear scanning, etc. And now so many people seem to work on the principle of "I have a wide screen, so I must have a picture which fills the entire width," even when the source material is 4:3, and deliberately distort the picture in order to achieve that.
The broadcasters aren't always too careful either. Sometimes you'll see a format change for, say, a commercial break, then after the return to the show it's in the wrong format for a minute or so until somebody eventually notices and switches it back. Or on the digital feeds they sometimes set the format flags incorrectly; I've seen instances in which 4:3 material was showing correctly on the analogue broadcast, but with a digital receiver coupled to a conventional 4:3 TV and set for letterbox widescreen mode, the format flags resulted in seeing a 4:3 image set within the widescreen frame which was itself then letterboxed into the 4:3 display, i.e. a 4:3 picture of the correct aspect ratio, but not filling an entire 4:3 screen leaving blank areas all around.
And then there are the widescreen-produced shows (not 16:9, but often a compromise widescreen) which include clips of older 4:3 material which has been expanded in order to fill most of the width, cropping off large amounts of the top and bottom of the original picture.
It's really become an absolute mess.
Originally posted by sixtyten
View Post
The broadcasters aren't always too careful either. Sometimes you'll see a format change for, say, a commercial break, then after the return to the show it's in the wrong format for a minute or so until somebody eventually notices and switches it back. Or on the digital feeds they sometimes set the format flags incorrectly; I've seen instances in which 4:3 material was showing correctly on the analogue broadcast, but with a digital receiver coupled to a conventional 4:3 TV and set for letterbox widescreen mode, the format flags resulted in seeing a 4:3 image set within the widescreen frame which was itself then letterboxed into the 4:3 display, i.e. a 4:3 picture of the correct aspect ratio, but not filling an entire 4:3 screen leaving blank areas all around.
And then there are the widescreen-produced shows (not 16:9, but often a compromise widescreen) which include clips of older 4:3 material which has been expanded in order to fill most of the width, cropping off large amounts of the top and bottom of the original picture.
It's really become an absolute mess.
Comment